November 2026

Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027

At present, “fire and rehire” remains a potentially lawful way of changing contractual terms where agreement cannot be reached. An employer can give notice of dismissal on existing contractual terms and offer re-engagement on amended terms. Such a dismissal may be fair for the potentially fair reason of “some other substantial reason” (SOSR), provided there is a sound business reason for the change and it has acted reasonably, including through proper consultation. The current statutory Code of Practice, introduced in 2024, already stresses that dismissal and re-engagement should be a last resort.

From March 2027, however, the landscape changes fundamentally. That implementation date itself is new: the reforms had previously been expected in January 2027.

Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, dismissal to impose a “restricted variation” will become automatically unfair unless the employer can satisfy a narrow financial difficulties exception. Restricted variations include:

  • reductions to pay or other sums payable in connection with employment;
  • changes to performance-related measures determining pay;
  • changes to pensions;
  • changes to total working hours;
  • specified changes to the timing or duration of shifts;
  • reductions in contractual time off; and
  • inserting a contractual power allowing the employer to make any of these changes without agreement.

The financial difficulties exception sets a deliberately high bar: broadly, the difficulties must threaten the organisation’s ability to continue as a going concern, and the employer must have been unable reasonably to avoid the need for the change. The new draft Code of Practice helpfully explains what financial difficulties might look like in the private sector, the public sector, and for local authority employers.

Dismissals to secure other, unrestricted changes will remain potentially fair for SOSR, but subject to a more demanding statutory fairness framework.

The Government’s draft revised Code of Practice provides the practical framework for this brave new world. There is, however, an unusual wrinkle. The existing 2024 Code is expected to be withdrawn when the new regime starts in March 2027, while the replacement Code is not expected to take effect until summer 2027 – potentially leaving employers navigating the new statutory regime for several months without a Code.

Are non-compete clauses on borrowed time?

Could the non-compete clause be on its way out? Prime Minister Andy Burnham has announced plans to legislate to tackle non-compete clauses, arguing that some businesses have gone “too far”, and that restrictions which leave workers sitting “on the sidelines” can stunt innovation and trap workers.

What can employers currently restrict?

Post-termination restrictions in an employment context generally involve contractual provisions which limit the freedom of the employee for a restricted period following the termination of their employment. They cover:

  • Non-solicitation clauses, preventing former employees from poaching clients or colleagues.
  • Non-dealing clauses, preventing them from doing business with clients, even where the client approaches them.
  • Non-compete clauses, preventing them from working for a competitor or setting up a competing business.

Non-competes are the most draconian because they can prevent someone earning a living in their chosen field.

All restrictive covenants are restraints of trade and are only enforceable where they go no further than is reasonably necessary to protect a legitimate business interest, such as confidential information or customer connections. For this reason, the drafting of such clauses is critical. Employers need to pick a limited duration (one year is generally the maximum that anyone would attempt to include) and need to be drafted as narrowly as possible.

But Government is concerned that this may not provide sufficient protection: employees may comply with an intimidating looking restriction rather than risk expensive litigation, even where the clause might ultimately be unenforceable.

So, what might change?

A recent Government working paper floated several possibilities: a statutory maximum duration; an outright ban; banning non-competes below a salary threshold; or combining a salary threshold with a time limit. The previous Government had proposed a three-month cap but never legislated.

There are other models. In France, for example, an enforceable non-compete must include financial compensation for the employee. The UK previously consulted on a similar “pay to restrict” approach.

For now, the destination is clearer than the route: Government intends to intervene. HR teams may therefore want to start asking whether non-competes are genuinely necessary, or whether carefully drafted confidentiality, non-solicitation and non-dealing provisions would adequately protect the business.

Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink?

Whistleblowing protection has been part of UK employment law for almost 30 years. Now, the Government is carrying out the widest review of the law since the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998.

So, what is the law now and what could change?

When is someone protected?

Not every complaint made at work is whistleblowing. To qualify for protection, a worker must disclose information which they reasonably believe shows one of seven types of wrongdoing. These include a criminal offence, breach of a legal obligation, danger to health and safety, environmental damage and a miscarriage of justice. Since April 2026, the list also specifically includes sexual harassment that has happened, is happening or is likely to happen.

The worker must also reasonably believe that their disclosure is in the public interest. This helps distinguish whistleblowing from a purely personal complaint, such as an individual dispute about their own contract.

Who they tell can also matter. Raising concerns with their employer is usually the most straightforward route to protection. Disclosures can also be made to certain outside organisations, known as “prescribed persons”, although additional rules apply.

If someone is protected as a whistleblower, they must not be subjected to a detriment because they spoke up. In simple terms, they must not be treated badly because of their disclosure. An employee who is dismissed for whistleblowing can also claim automatically unfair dismissal.

There is an additional remedy called interim relief. In some whistleblowing dismissal cases, an employee can ask a tribunal to effectively preserve their employment or pay until the full case is decided. The current deadline for applying is extremely short: just seven days after dismissal.

What could change?

The Government is considering extending whistleblowing protection to more people, including some self-employed individuals, non-executive directors, charity trustees and job applicants. It is also looking at changing the rules about what can be disclosed and who concerns can be raised with.

For HR, one of the biggest proposals is a new legal duty to have whistleblowing policies and procedures. This could apply to private sector employers with 50 or more employees, with civil penalties for getting it wrong.

Other proposals include extending the interim relief deadline from seven to fourteen days and introducing financial rewards for some whistleblowers who report economic crime to the Serious Fraud Office.

Nothing has changed yet. But the direction is important: employers may increasingly be expected not simply to protect whistleblowers, but to have effective systems in place that make it safe for people to speak up.

The consultation closes on 8 January 2027.

Fire and rehire: which contractual changes will get special protection?

New fire and rehire rules are due to come into force in March 2027. One of the first questions HR will need to ask when proposing changes to employees’ contracts is: is this a “restricted variation”? That matters because restricted variations receive much stronger protection under the new rules. A decision to dismiss in order to make a restricted variation to contractual terms will be automatically unfair unless the employer is able to rely upon a very narrow ‘business distress’ exemption.

Restricted variations already include changes to important contractual terms such as pay, pensions, hours and time off. The Government has now confirmed how some less obvious changes will be treated.

Most expenses and benefits in kind will fall outside the restricted category. However, contractual travel expenses (including mileage), accommodation expenses, and long-term accommodation provided as a benefit in kind will be included. Share schemes will not.

Some significant changes to shift patterns will also be restricted. For example, this will include requiring someone who previously worked during the day to work nights (11pm–6am) or requiring someone who worked weekdays to work weekends. Smaller changes, such as moving a daytime shift by a few hours, will not be restricted.

There is another important point: the right must be contractual in the first place. Changing a genuinely non-contractual benefit, or making a change already permitted by the contract, may therefore be treated differently.

So why does all this matter?

If an employee is dismissed because they refuse to accept a restricted variation, their dismissal will generally be automatically unfair. There is only a narrow exception where the employer is facing serious financial difficulties.

Other contractual changes do not receive that same protection. A dismissal to impose an unrestricted variation may still be unfair, but the tribunal will be applying ordinary unfair dismissal principles, looking at matters such as the employer’s reasons, consultation and what was offered to employees in return. The only slight ‘tweak’ to this set out in the ERA 2025 changes is that the tribunal will additionally look at a statutory checklist when considering fairness. The checklist comprises the reason for the variation, the extent of consultation, and incentives offered for agreement.

The practical message for HR? Before starting any contractual change exercise, identify exactly what you want to change, check the existing contract and establish which set of rules applies.

Pregnancy and family leave: new dismissal protection from October 2027

Employees who are pregnant, on maternity leave or taking other types of family leave, already have additional protection against dismissal. From October 2027, those protections are going to become significantly stronger.

The Government has now confirmed how new rules introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025 will work in practice.

The important point is that employers will still be able to dismiss a protected employee for one of the usual potentially fair reasons – conduct, capability, redundancy, illegality or some other substantial reason. However, it will become harder for an employer to show that the dismissal was fair.

At present, an employer generally needs to show that its decision to dismiss was reasonable in the circumstances, and fell within the ‘band of reasonable responses’ an employer might have in a given situation. There may be several ‘fair’ outcomes. If a tribunal prefers an alternative outcome but dismissal is one of the options that falls within the ‘reasonable responses’ band, then the dismissal will be fair. The tribunal cannot substitute its own view for that of the employer. Under the new rules, where an employee is within the protected period, the employer will instead have to show that dismissal was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This is a harder test for the employer to meet. In practical terms, HR will need to ask: was dismissal really necessary, or was there another reasonable way of dealing with the situation?

For example, before dismissing, an employer may need to consider whether additional support, temporary changes to duties, adjustments or an alternative role could address the problem instead.

The protection will apply from day one of employment. For pregnant employees, it will start when they tell their employer they are pregnant. It will continue during maternity leave and for six months after that leave ends. Similar protection will apply to employees taking adoption leave (starting from the day adoption leave starts) and certain other types of family leave, including shared parental, bereaved partners paternity leave, and neonatal care leave (where protection will apply during leave and, provided a period of at least six continuous weeks of leave are taken, for six months following return).

The existing special rules protecting pregnant employees and new parents in redundancy situations will also continue to apply.

For HR, the key message is simple: spot when the enhanced protection applies and take extra care before dismissal. From October 2027, simply showing that dismissal was a reasonable response may not be enough.

Harassment: five questions HR should ask

When does an inappropriate comment at work cross the line into unlawful harassment? A recent EAT decision provides a useful reminder that the answer is not simply whether the employee was offended.

In McManus v British Airways, a cabin crew member with anxiety and depression was told during an occupational health assessment that Access to Work was “not for people like you, it’s for people in wheelchairs”.

She felt harassed by the comment, but her Equality Act harassment claim ultimately failed.

So, when HR is faced with a harassment complaint, what should it be asking?

  1. Was the conduct unwanted?

There must first be unwanted conduct. This can include words, actions, jokes, images or other behaviour.

  1. Was it related to a protected characteristic?

For most Equality Act harassment claims, there must be a connection between the conduct and a relevant protected characteristic. In McManus, the comment related to disability.

  1. What was the purpose or effect?

The conduct must have the purpose or effect of violating the employee’s dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.

  1. How did the employee perceive it?

If relying on the effect of the conduct, the employee must actually have experienced the prohibited effect. Their perception therefore matters.

  1. Was it reasonable for the conduct to have that effect?

This is the important final check. HR should consider all the circumstances, not simply whether somebody was upset or offended.

McManus confirms that those circumstances can include the employee’s mental ill health. However, this does not mean that their perception automatically becomes objectively reasonable.

The HR takeaway? Harassment is highly context specific. Investigations should look beyond the words used and consider the employee, the circumstances and the context before reaching conclusions.

Employment status: is the worker test about to change?

Employee, worker or self-employed? Getting employment status right matters because it determines which employment rights someone receives.

Employees have the widest range of rights, including protection against unfair dismissal and the right to a redundancy payment. “Workers” have fewer rights but still benefit from important protections including the National Minimum Wage and paid holiday. Genuinely self-employed people generally fall outside the employment rights framework.

The difficulty is that working out which category someone falls into is not always easy.

Why does substitution matter?

At the moment, someone must normally be required to carry out the work personally to qualify as either an employee or a worker.

This means that substitution can be important. If someone has a genuine and unrestricted right to send somebody else to do the work in their place, that can point strongly towards them being self-employed rather than a worker.

The Government is concerned that this can sometimes produce the wrong result. Someone might be closely controlled by the organisation they work for, for example, but still miss out on worker rights because they have a genuine right to provide a substitute.

It is therefore consulting on whether “significant direction or control” should become another way of establishing worker status. In practice, this would mean looking more closely at how much control an organisation has over the individual, rather than allowing a right of substitution to determine the issue.

And this may only be the beginning…

The Government is also considering introducing a presumption that someone is a worker when they bring certain employment tribunal claims. It would then be for the organisation engaging them to show that they are not.

Looking further ahead, the Government’s ambition is more significant still. It ultimately wants to replace the current employee and worker categories with a single status of “worker”, with everyone within that category potentially receiving full employment rights.

For now, nothing has changed and the existing three categories remain in place. HR teams do not need to start rewriting consultancy agreements just yet. But organisations which regularly use contractors, freelancers or gig workers should keep a close eye on developments. Changes to the test could mean that more people qualify for employment rights in future.

The Government’s consultation closes on 8 January 2027.

Mitigation of loss: who has to prove what?

Winning an employment tribunal claim does not necessarily mean an employee will recover every penny they lose afterwards.

Employees are expected to take reasonable steps to “mitigate” their loss. In an unfair dismissal case, that will usually mean making reasonable efforts to find alternative work rather than simply allowing losses to accumulate.

But there is an important point about the burden of proof. It is for the employer to show that the employee has acted unreasonably by failing to mitigate their loss. It is not for the employee to prove that everything they did was reasonable.

The EAT’s decision in Kirkland v Mason is a useful reminder of that distinction.

What happened?

Ms Kirkland was summarily dismissed from her part-time administration manager role and successfully claimed unfair dismissal.

At the remedy hearing, she claimed 19 months’ lost earnings. The tribunal awarded only six months, saying it was not satisfied that she had mitigated her losses. It considered that she had chosen to prioritise a growing short-term property letting business over finding other work.

The EAT overturned that decision.

The tribunal had asked the wrong question. It needed to decide whether the employer had proved that Ms Kirkland had acted unreasonably in failing to mitigate her losses. The tribunal had made no such finding.

What does this mean for HR?

If an employer wants to argue that compensation should be reduced for failure to mitigate, it needs to be ready to prove its case.

That may mean gathering evidence of suitable alternative jobs available during the relevant period, carrying out job-market searches, and working with recruitment businesses to demonstrate the opportunities realistically open to the claimant.

Simply pointing to gaps in the claimant’s job search may not be enough.

Mitigation arguments therefore need to be employer-led and evidence-based. If reducing compensation matters, start gathering that evidence rather than expecting the employee to prove the opposite.

When your star performer is causing problems

What do you do when someone is brilliant at their job, but increasingly difficult to work with?

It can be tempting to tolerate the behaviour, particularly where the individual is commercially important or difficult to replace. The problem with waiting is that relatively manageable concerns can develop into something much harder to resolve.

Muir v AstraZeneca UK Ltd provides a useful example.

Dr Muir was a technical lead working on a project to develop a breast cancer drug. Colleagues made informal complaints about his overly forceful manner, but he was not initially made aware of how his behaviour was being perceived.

Eventually, matters escalated and he was dismissed for gross misconduct. He successfully claimed unfair dismissal and disability discrimination.

The tribunal considered that AstraZeneca should have intervened much earlier. Dr Muir was unaware of the impact his behaviour was having. The company also knew that he had mental health issues and was experiencing stress as an important project deadline approached.

Don’t wait for the formal complaint

The lesson for HR is not that difficult behaviour should be tolerated. Quite the opposite.

Early intervention could mean an informal conversation about how someone is coming across, management or communication training, clearer behavioural expectations, or support with workload and stress.

That can be particularly important with high performers. Technical expertise can sometimes mean that behavioural problems are dismissed as quirks or the price of getting results.

But avoiding the conversation may be unfair to everyone involved, including the manager who is given no opportunity to change.

The better approach is to spot the pattern and intervene early. Waiting until colleagues are making formal complaints and the employer has lost patience can turn a manageable people problem into a disciplinary process, resignations or litigation.

And finally… Captain Kirk comes to the rescue of an ex-Aldi employee

It is not every payroll dispute that attracts the attention of the captain of the USS Enterprise.

But William Shatner, better known as Star Trek’s Captain Kirk, recently waded into a row between Aldi and a former employee over a £97.64 wage overpayment.

The employee’s father, radio presenter Chris Brooks, posted on X after his son received a letter from Aldi seeking repayment following the end of his employment. Brooks described the letter as “intimidating”, particularly because it warned of debt recovery action if payment was not made by a date which, according to Brooks, had already passed before the letter was even sent.

Enter Captain Kirk.

Shatner responded publicly, criticising Aldi’s accounting department and suggesting that the company should work out how much it had spent pursuing the debt. He suspected it might be more than the £97 at stake.

There is, however, a serious HR point lurking beneath the celebrity intervention.

Employers are generally entitled to recover genuine accidental overpayments of wages. While someone remains employed, an overpayment is also one of the recognised exceptions to the usual restrictions on deductions from wages. But where employment has already ended and there are no further wages from which to make a deduction, the employer will normally need to ask the former employee to repay the money and, ultimately, consider a civil claim if they refuse. Acas recommends explaining the overpayment and being fair and flexible about repayment.

Having a legal right to recover money does not mean it needs to be exercised at maximum warp speed.

A proportionate first letter explaining what has happened, apologising for the employer’s error and inviting the individual to discuss repayment is likely to achieve more than an immediate threat of debt recovery, particularly where the sum is modest.

In this case, Aldi subsequently apologised for the concern caused and confirmed that it would not pursue the money after all.

Perhaps the HR lesson is simple: before sending the stern template letter, consider whether a more human approach might help everyone to live long and prosper.

Practical Perspectives

Scroll to Top